Sports Contests

NFL Playoff Pool: The Best Formats, How Scoring Works and How to Win

6 min read
NFL playoff pool bracket and scoring

The regular season is over, your fantasy league crowned its champion, and the group chat goes quiet for about a day before somebody asks, "Are we doing a playoff pool?" Yes. You are. An NFL playoff pool has everyone pick the winners of the playoff games, from wild card weekend through the Super Bowl, and score points for each correct pick, usually more for the later rounds. Most points after the Super Bowl wins.

It's the shortest football pool of the year, 13 games across four rounds, which means one bad call costs more than it would in a regular-season pick'em. It also means a well-built plan can beat a pool full of people who just picked their favorite teams. Here's how the common formats work and how we'd play each one.

How the NFL playoffs are set up

Fourteen teams make the field, seven from the AFC and seven from the NFC. In each conference, the four division winners take seeds 1 through 4, and three wild card teams take 5 through 7. The No. 1 seed gets a bye through the first round.

The rounds run like this: six wild card games, four divisional games, two conference championships, and the Super Bowl. After the first round, the NFL reseeds, so the top seed left always plays the lowest seed left. That last part trips people up in bracket pools. You can't fill in the divisional round until you know which wild card teams won.

Common NFL playoff pool formats

Round-by-round pick'em

The simplest version. Before each round, you pick the winners of that round's games. Because you pick one round at a time, you always know the real matchups. Some pools pick straight up, some against the point spread. Weekly pick'em habits carry over well here, and our notes on beating a crowded pick'em pool apply round by round.

NFL playoff bracket pool

You fill out the whole NFL playoff bracket before wild card weekend, March Madness style, and it's the most popular office pool format of the postseason. Reseeding makes it a little messier than a college bracket, so most bracket pools either reseed for you on paper or simply ask you to pick each conference's champion and the Super Bowl winner. One early upset can wreck a bracket, so the points usually climb steeply by round.

Confidence playoff pool

You rank your picks. With six wild card games, your surest pick gets 6 points and your least sure gets 1, and so on each round. It rewards knowing which games are close and which aren't. Ranking well is a skill on its own; here's how we order confidence points in a regular-season pool, and the same thinking works in January.

Playoff survivor

Pick one team each round to win; lose and you're out, and you can't reuse a team. With only four rounds and a shrinking field of teams, the "save your best team" puzzle shows up fast. Do you use the top seed in the divisional round, or keep it for the conference title game? Survivor fans will recognize the problem from the regular-season survivor format.

Playoff fantasy

Instead of teams, you pick players: a quarterback, running backs, receivers, a kicker and a defense, usually with a rule that each NFL team can only appear once or twice on your roster. Your players score fantasy points for every playoff game their team plays. The catch is that a great player on a team that loses in the wild card round gives you one game. A good player on a wild card team that runs all the way to the Super Bowl gives you four.

Super Bowl squares

Not a playoff pool exactly, but most groups run squares for the big game too. It's pure luck once the numbers are drawn, which is half the charm. Some groups run a playoff version where every game gets its own grid and the numbers are redrawn each round. If that's your thing, the way our NFL squares work is laid out on its own page.

Scoring systems that work

The scoring decides how much each round matters, so it's worth getting right before anyone picks. The most popular system doubles each round:

RoundGamesPoints per correct pickMost points possible
Wild card616
Divisional428
Conference championships248
Super Bowl188

Each round is worth about the same in total, which keeps the pool alive into February. If you want the Super Bowl to decide it, give the champion more. If you want early skill to count, flatten the curve. Either way, write it down before wild card weekend.

Bracket pools often add upset bonuses, say an extra point for each seed of difference when an underdog wins. They make the pool more fun and reward the person willing to back a 6 seed on the road.

How to win an NFL playoff pool

Start with the betting lines. Playoff spreads are some of the sharpest numbers of the year, and they tell you how likely each team is to win better than any power ranking. A 3-point favorite wins a little more than half the time; a 9-point favorite wins most of the time but still loses now and then. You can see the current numbers and where the public is leaning on our NFL betting percentages page.

In a small pool, pick the most likely winner almost every time. In a big pool, you need to be different somewhere, because the people picking all favorites will tie each other. The smart place to be different is a close game where the crowd has piled onto one side. Being different on a lopsided game is just being wrong more often.

In bracket formats, your Super Bowl pick is the most valuable decision you make. Pick a champion you believe in, then pick the rest of the bracket so it's consistent with that team getting there. A bracket that has the 1 seed losing in the divisional round and then winning the Super Bowl is a bracket that wasn't thought through.

Watch the weather and injuries, too. A January game in the snow lowers scoring and can favor the better running team. A quarterback listed as questionable on Friday changes everything. If your pool locks picks round by round, wait for the final injury reports.

And don't forget the tiebreaker. Most playoff pools break ties with the total points in the Super Bowl, and the betting total for that game is the best place to start. We wrote up how to make a sharper tiebreaker guess for weekly pools; the same logic applies here.

Running your own office pool for the playoffs

If you're the commissioner, keep it simple. A free app or pool hosting site will keep track of the standings for you, or a printable bracket works fine for a small group. Pick one format, one scoring system and one tiebreaker, post them before the wild card games, and set the deadline at the first kickoff of each round. Free pools are the easiest to run and the most fun for groups where half the people only watch football in January. If you add an entry fee, keep it small, collect it up front, and know your state's rules on pools. Most pool members care more about bragging rights than the money anyway.

If you ask us, the best playoff pool is the one where the whole group is still checking the standings during the Super Bowl halftime show. Doubling points by round does that better than anything.

After the Super Bowl

When the confetti falls, football pools go dark until September. Our Streak keeps going: free picks on spreads and totals in basketball and hockey, then baseball in the spring, with cash for runs of 15, 17, 19 and 21 wins. Check the longest active runs right now if you want to see what you're up against.

You must be 21 or older to play. Keep pools friendly, keep the stakes small, and if gambling stops being fun, call 1-800-GAMBLER.

FAQ

How does an NFL playoff pool work?
Players make picks on the NFL playoff games, from the wild card round to the Super Bowl, and score points for every correct pick. Most pools give more points in later rounds. The player with the most points after the Super Bowl wins.
How many games are in the NFL playoffs?
Thirteen: six wild card games, four divisional games, two conference championships and the Super Bowl. Fourteen teams make the field, seven from each conference, and the top seed in each conference skips the wild card round.
What is a good scoring system for an NFL playoff pool?
A common one doubles each round: 1 point per wild card winner, 2 per divisional winner, 4 per conference champion and 8 for the Super Bowl winner. It keeps the early rounds relevant without letting them decide the pool.
What is a playoff fantasy pool?
Each player drafts or picks NFL players before the playoffs and keeps them for every round their team plays. A player on a team that reaches the Super Bowl can score in three or four games, depending on whether it had a bye, so picking who goes deep matters as much as who's good.
What's the tiebreaker in a playoff pool?
Usually the total points scored in the Super Bowl. Closest guess wins, sometimes without going over. Start from the Super Bowl betting total when you make yours.

Build a streak today

15 in a row = $100 · 21 in a row = $1,500 · Free to play.

Join free

More from Sports Contests