Sports Contests

NFL Pick'em Tiebreaker: How Ties Are Broken (and How to Win Them)

3 min read
NFL pick'em tiebreaker rules

In most NFL pick'em pools, the tiebreaker is a guess at the total points scored in the last game of the week, usually Monday Night Football. If two players finish the week with the same number of correct picks, the one whose guess is closest to the real total wins. Some pools add a second tiebreaker or simply split the prize.

Tiebreakers decide more weeks than you'd think. In a pool where everyone picks the same favorites, a lot of players end up on the same score. Here's how pick'em tiebreakers usually work, how to make a better guess, and a quick look at how the NFL itself breaks ties in the standings.

How NFL pick'em tiebreakers work

The common version runs like this:

  1. Along with your picks, you enter a number: the total points you think both teams will score in the week's final game.
  2. When the week ends, the pool counts correct picks.
  3. If players are tied on correct picks, the one whose tiebreaker guess is closest to the actual total wins the week.

Read the exact wording in your pool's rules. Two versions are common:

  • Closest wins: a guess of 44 beats a guess of 50 when the final total is 46, whether over or under.
  • Closest without going over: any guess above the real total loses the tiebreaker, like a game show. A guess of 44 beats 47 when the final total is 46.

Backup tiebreakers and split prizes

Two players can still tie on the tiebreaker. Pools handle that in a few ways:

  • A second guess, like the winning team's score or the total yards in the same game.
  • The earliest submitted entry wins.
  • The players split the prize.

Season-long standings usually add up weekly points, and ties at the end of the season are often settled by total tiebreaker accuracy over the year or by splitting the prize. On Streak for the Cash, players who tie for a place in the Monthly Contest share the prize money for the places they cover; the contest rules have the details.

How to make a smarter tiebreaker guess

  • Start from the betting total. The over/under for the Monday night game is the best estimate of combined points you'll find. If the total is 45.5, a guess between 42 and 48 is sensible.
  • Shade down for "closest without going over." Going over loses outright, so guess a few points under the total.
  • Mind the key numbers. NFL games often land on totals built from field goals and touchdowns, like 37, 41, 44, 47 and 51. A guess near one of those is a little more likely to be close.
  • Check the weather. Wind and rain cut scoring. If the game is outdoors in bad weather, shade lower.
  • Think about where you stand. If you're behind in a season-long pool, a guess away from everyone else's gives you a chance to win weeks on your own.

How the NFL breaks ties in the standings

Many people searching for NFL tiebreakers want the league's own rules for playoff seeding and the division race. When two teams finish the regular season with the same record, the NFL works down a list until one team comes out ahead:

  1. Head-to-head record between the tied teams.
  2. Record in division games (for teams in the same division) or conference games (for a wild card spot).
  3. Record in common games, against opponents both teams played.
  4. Strength of victory: the combined winning percentage of the teams they beat.
  5. Strength of schedule: the combined winning percentage of all their opponents.
  6. Rankings in points scored and points allowed, then net points.
  7. A coin toss, as a last resort that's almost never needed.

The full official rules have more steps and separate procedures for three or more tied teams and for the draft order, where the team with the weaker strength of schedule picks first. For pick'em purposes, the main thing to know is that division games and head-to-head results matter most late in the season.

Win more weeks before the tiebreaker matters

The best way to handle tiebreakers is to need them less. Our NFL pick'em playbook covers how to use the lines and when to go against the crowd, and winning a pick'em pool over a full season gets its own guide.

Want to test your picks for free? The Streak on Streak for the Cash is a free contest with cash prizes for long winning streaks, and there's no tiebreaker to worry about: one wrong pick and you start over. Start a free streak and see how far you get.

You must be 21 or older to play. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

FAQ

How does the tiebreaker work in NFL pick'em?
Most pools ask you to guess the total points scored in the last game of the week, usually Monday Night Football. If two players finish with the same number of correct picks, the one whose guess is closest to the real total wins.
What is a good tiebreaker number for Monday Night Football?
Start from the betting total for that game, which is the market's estimate of combined points. If your pool uses 'closest without going over,' shade a few points below it.
What happens if the tiebreaker is also tied?
Pools use a second tiebreaker, such as the winning team's points, total yards or who entered first, or they split the prize. Check your pool's rules before Week 1.
How do NFL standings tiebreakers work?
When two teams finish with the same record, the NFL looks first at head-to-head results, then division or conference record, common games, strength of victory and strength of schedule, with a coin toss as the last resort.

Build a streak today

15 in a row = $100 · 21 in a row = $1,500 · Free to play.

Join free

More from Sports Contests