Sports Contests

Super Bowl Pick'em: How the Big Game Prop Pool Works and How to Win It

6 min read
Super Bowl pick'em prop sheet

Super Bowl Sunday, about an hour before kickoff. Somebody's printing a sheet, somebody's arguing about the length of the national anthem, and somebody's cousin who doesn't watch football is about to win the whole thing because she picked "tails." That's a Super Bowl pick'em. Everyone answers the same list of questions about the big game, from who wins and who covers to the first touchdown scorer and the game MVP, and each right answer scores points. Most points at the final whistle takes the prize.

It's the most popular football contest of the year for people who don't play football contests. That's exactly why a little homework goes a long way. Most of the room is guessing.

How a Super Bowl pick'em works

The host makes a list of questions, usually 15 to 30, and everyone answers them before kickoff. A few are about the game result. Most are props, the side questions about what happens during the game. Each right answer is worth a set number of points, often one point each, sometimes more for the harder ones. The tiebreaker is almost always a guess at the total points scored.

Online versions work the same way. You make your picks in an app before the game, and the standings update live as each question gets answered. Plenty of them are free to play, which makes them an easy way to compete with a big group without anyone collecting cash.

The other popular Super Bowl contest is squares, which is all luck once the numbers are drawn. If that's the one your group runs, here's a full rundown of the squares grid, and if you get to choose your numbers, read up on which digits hit most often.

Free Super Bowl pick'em games

You don't need a host in your office to play. Once the AFC and NFC championship games set the matchup, the big sports networks, NFL apps and fantasy sites roll out free Super Bowl pick'em games, and plenty of them let you win a prize just for answering a handful of questions on the big game. They work like a normal NFL football pick'em from the regular season: sign up, make your predictions before kickoff, and watch the standings move with every touchdown. The free ones are the easy way to compete against thousands of people at once, and the odds of finishing first are about what you'd expect with a crowd that size.

Some groups also run a pick'em game across the whole postseason, from the wild card round and divisional round through the Super Bowl, with the big game worth the most points.

Questions you'll see on most sheets

Every sheet is different, but the same types show up year after year:

  • Who wins the game, and who covers the spread
  • Over or under the total points
  • The coin toss: heads or tails, and who wins it
  • Which team scores first, and how (touchdown or field goal)
  • First touchdown scorer
  • Game MVP
  • Will there be a safety, a missed extra point, or overtime
  • Player stats: passing yards, rushing yards, receptions for the stars
  • Halftime leader, highest-scoring quarter
  • Entertainment questions: anthem length, Gatorade color, halftime songs

The first half of that list is football. The last few items are coin flips dressed up as questions. Your edge comes from getting the football ones right more often than the room.

How to fill out a Super Bowl pick'em sheet

Let the betting odds do the first pass

Sportsbooks post odds on almost every prop on a typical sheet, and those prices are a better guess than anyone's gut. If a quarterback's passing yards line is 265.5, the market thinks over and under are close to even. If "will there be a safety" is a big plus-money price on yes, the answer is probably no. Go question by question and start from what the odds say.

Know which questions reward research

Game winner, spread and total are the obvious ones. Player stat props reward knowing the matchup: a team that gives up a lot of yards to tight ends, or a running back who gets every goal-line carry. The MVP award goes to a quarterback more often than any other position, and nearly always to someone on the winning team, so the quarterback of the team you think wins is a sensible default. A defensive player or receiver can steal it, but don't bet the sheet on it.

Don't overthink the coin toss

Heads or tails is 50-50 every year. So is which team wins the toss. Pick fast and move on. People who spend ten minutes on the coin toss and ten seconds on the total are giving away points.

Be different in the right spots

In a small group, just pick the most likely answer to everything. In a big pool, the favorite answers will be on half the sheets, and you'll end up tied with all of them. Pick two or three close questions, where the odds are near even, and take the side the room probably won't. That's where you can climb past the crowd without giving up much. Being contrarian on a lopsided question just costs you a point.

Make your answers agree with each other

If you pick one team to win by a lot, your over/under, first score and MVP answers should fit that story. A sheet that has the underdog winning, a low total and the favorite's quarterback as MVP is fighting itself.

Use the tiebreaker

Pools come down to the tiebreaker more often than you'd expect. Start from the game's betting total, then nudge it based on your read of the game. Our guide to picking a smart total-points tiebreaker goes through the details, including what to do when the rule is "closest without going over."

Running a Super Bowl pick'em for your group

Keep the sheet to 20 or 25 questions. Mix in a handful of football questions with real answers, a few player props and a couple of fun ones for the non-fans. Give harder questions more points if you want knowledge to matter. Lock the sheet at kickoff, write the tiebreaker rule at the top, and have a plan for questions that end up void, like a player who doesn't suit up.

If money is involved, keep it small and know your state's rules on pools. A free sheet with bragging rights gets more people playing anyway.

Before the big game

If your season-long survivor entry died back in October, the Super Bowl sheet is your shot at redemption. It's the last football contest of the year, but it shouldn't be your first. The playoff weeks before it are a great warm-up, and we wrote up how January playoff pools score if your group wants one. Want a reality check on how well you read NFL games? The model's picks for every game are free to compare against yours, and our Streak lets you put your reads to work on spreads and totals all year, with cash for runs of 15 or more wins. That tells you a lot more about your football brain than one sheet in February.

You must be 21 or older to play. Keep it friendly, keep the stakes small, and if gambling stops being fun, call 1-800-GAMBLER.

FAQ

What is a Super Bowl pick'em?
A contest where everyone answers the same list of questions about the Super Bowl: who wins, who covers the spread, over or under the total, the first team to score, the game MVP and other props. Each right answer scores points, and the most points wins.
How many questions are on a Super Bowl pick'em sheet?
It varies. Office sheets often have 15 to 30 questions, and online prop pools usually land in the same range. More questions make luck matter less and knowledge matter more.
How do you win a Super Bowl prop pool?
Use the betting odds for each prop to pick the most likely answer, then be different from the crowd on a few close questions. In a big pool, a sheet full of favorites ties with everyone else's.
What's the usual tiebreaker in a Super Bowl pick'em?
The total points scored in the game, closest guess wins. Some pools add a second tiebreaker such as the winning team's score or total yards.
Is the coin toss worth thinking about?
Not really. It's a 50-50 guess every year, so pick heads or tails and spend your time on the questions where research helps.

Build a streak today

15 in a row = $100 · 21 in a row = $1,500 · Free to play.

Join free

More from Sports Contests