Sports Contests

Confidence Pool Strategy: How to Rank Your Picks and Win More Points

5 min read
NFL confidence pool strategy

The best confidence pool strategy is to rank your picks by how likely each team is to win, using the betting odds, and give the most points to the safest picks. Then, depending on how big your pool is, shuffle a few picks to be different from the field, mostly in the middle and bottom of your card, not at the top.

Confidence pools are our favorite kind of pick'em pool, because they reward thinking as much as picking. Two people can choose the exact same winners and finish miles apart because of how they handed out their points.

How an NFL confidence pool works

In an NFL confidence pool you pick the winner of every game that week, then assign each pick a confidence point value. With 16 games, you use every number from 16 down to 1 exactly once. A correct pick scores its points; a wrong pick scores zero. If you get every game right, you score 16 + 15 + ... + 1 = 136 points. On a 14-game week with byes, the top is 14 and the most you can score is 105.

Most pools pay a weekly winner, a season-long winner, or both. Some score against the point spread instead of straight up, and a few use a fixed point scale no matter how many games there are. Check your pool rules first, because they change the best move more than anything else in this guide.

Rank picks by win probability

The single biggest edge in a confidence pool is ranking by real win probabilities instead of by gut feel. The cleanest source is the moneyline. For a favorite, divide the moneyline by itself plus 100: -400 is 400 ÷ 500 = 80%, and -150 is 150 ÷ 250 = 60%. Here's a six-game example with points from 6 down to 1:

Favorite's moneylineWin probabilityConfidence pointsExpected points
-40080.0%64.80
-25071.4%53.57
-18064.3%42.57
-15060.0%31.80
-12555.6%21.11
-11052.4%10.52

Expected points add up to 14.38. If you put the same six picks in the reverse order, with the coin flip on 6 and the big favorite on 1, you'd expect only 12.48. Same winners, nearly 2 points a week thrown away, just from the order. Over a full NFL season, a gap like that decides pools, which is why our NFL pick'em game plan builds the ordering into a weekly routine.

These percentages include the sportsbook's cut, so they run a bit high. That doesn't matter much here. You only need the order right. If moneylines feel like too much work, the point spread gives nearly the same ranking: a 10-point favorite goes above a 3-point favorite every time.

Where underdogs belong

If you pick an underdog to win, you've already said the game is close, so it almost always belongs on your lowest numbers. Picking a dog and then putting 12 points on it is how a decent week turns into a bad one.

The low end of your card is also where upsets cost you the least. Swap a 52% favorite for its 48% underdog on 1 point and you give up a few hundredths of a point in expected value. That's a cheap way to have a different card from the rest of the field.

Weekly prizes vs. season-long prizes

Season-long standings reward consistency. Rank by win probability, take very few risks, and let the points pile up. The players who win season-long confidence pools usually aren't the ones with the best single week. They're the ones who never had a terrible one.

Weekly prizes are a different game. With 30 people in a pool, somebody usually has a great week, and you need to beat that person, not the average. That means a few calculated risks: one or two well-chosen upsets, and some of your middle points on games where the pool is heavily on one side.

Pool size and pick popularity

In a small pool of 10 or so, straight probability ranking is very hard to beat. In a bigger pool, think about what everyone else is doing. If almost the whole pool has the same team at 16 and it wins, nobody gains on anybody. If it loses, everyone misses the same 16 points. Either way, that pick doesn't separate you from the field.

Where you can separate is in the order. Say the top favorite is 80% to win and your next-best pick is 70%. Putting the 80% team on 16 and the 70% team on 13 gives 21.9 expected points from those two picks. Swap them and it's 21.6. You've given up 0.3 points of expected value for a card that looks different from most of your pool's. In a 200-person pool that trade is often worth making; in a 12-person office pool it usually isn't.

Our NFL consensus page shows which side most players are on for each game, a decent proxy for pick popularity in your own pool.

Late news, stale lines and injury reports

Confidence picks are only as good as the probabilities behind them. If your pool locks all picks before the Thursday game, use the latest lines you can get on Thursday and be careful with Sunday games where a starting quarterback's status is unclear. Drop those a few points rather than leaving them at the top.

In a pool scored against the spread, watch for stale lines. Some pools set their spreads early in the week. If the market has moved two or three points since then, often because of injury reports, the pool's line may now favor one side, and that pick deserves more confidence than it would at the real number.

Common confidence pool mistakes

The most common one is ranking by how much you like a team rather than how likely it is to win. Close behind it: putting big points on your favorite team, loading high points on underdogs to make up for a bad week, and forgetting that Thursday and international games can lock earlier than the rest. Keep your process the same every week and you'll avoid most of them.

Practice the skill year-round

Ranking games by probability is the same skill whether you're filling out a confidence card or making one pick at a time. Between pool weeks, Streak for the Cash's free Streak and Monthly Contest let you test your reads against real lines for cash prizes, with no entry fee. It's one of several free contests with real prize money worth playing alongside your pool.

Streak for the Cash is for players 21 and over. If betting ever stops being fun, call or text 1-800-GAMBLER for free, confidential help.

FAQ

How does a confidence pool work?
You pick the winner of every game and give each pick a different point value, from the number of games down to 1. A correct pick scores its points, a wrong one scores nothing, and the most points wins.
Where should you put an upset pick in a confidence pool?
Usually on low points. If you're taking an underdog, you already think it's close, so it belongs near the bottom. In big pools you can move one up to the middle to separate yourself.
Should you use point spreads to rank confidence picks?
Yes, as a guide. The bigger the spread, the more likely the favorite wins straight up, so spreads give you a quick ranking. Moneylines are a little more precise if you want to turn them into win probabilities.
What if my pool's games aren't the same every week?
Byes change the number of games, so the top value changes too. A 14-game week runs from 14 down to 1, for 105 points. The ranking method stays the same.

Build a streak today

15 in a row = $100 · 21 in a row = $1,500 · Free to play.

Join free

More from Sports Contests