Sports Contests

How to Win Pick'em Pools: Strategy for Every Format and Pool Size

7 min read
How to win pick'em pools

To win a pick'em pool, pick the team the betting odds favor in most games, save your upsets for close games where most of your pool is on the other side, and know your pool's scoring and tiebreaker before the first kickoff. That's most of it. The rest is matching how bold you are to how big your pool is and how much time is left.

We've run free sports contests for years, and the people who win pools are rarely the ones who know the most football. They're the ones who use the odds, read the rules and think about what everyone else in the pool is picking.

Know which pick'em format you're playing

A pick'em pool is any contest where you pick the winners of a set of games, usually a full NFL week or a college football slate, and score a point for every correct pick. Most pools come in one of three flavors, and the best pool strategy is different in each.

Straight-up pools

You just pick the game winner. Favorites win most NFL games, so a card of all favorites is a solid baseline, and the gap between the top of the standings and the middle is small. Here, the few close games decide the week.

Against the spread pools

You pick who covers the point spread. If a team is a 6-point favorite, it needs to win by 7 or more for a pick on it to count; if it wins by 5, the underdog pick wins. The spread is built to make each game close to a coin flip, so the standings swing more and luck plays a bigger part. Your edge comes from small things: lines that were set early in the week and have since moved, and injury news the pool's line doesn't reflect.

Confidence pools

You pick winners and also rank them, giving your most confident pick the most points. In a 16-game week, points run from 16 down to 1, for 136 total. Where you put your points matters as much as who you pick, so we've written a separate guide to confidence pool tactics.

Read your pool's rules before you make a pick

Five minutes with the rules of your pool can change your whole approach. Check whether there's a weekly prize, a season-long prize or both. Check when picks lock: all at once before the first game of the week, or game by game. Check what a missed pick counts as, how ties and pushes are scored, and what the tiebreaker is. A pool that locks everything before Thursday Night Football is a different game from one that lets you wait for Sunday morning injury reports.

Use the betting odds as your starting point

The betting markets are the best free forecast you'll find. Millions of dollars push the lines toward the real chances, and they're very hard to beat by gut feel. Turn a moneyline into a win probability like this: for a favorite at -150, it's 150 ÷ (150 + 100) = 60%. For an underdog at +130, it's 100 ÷ (130 + 100) = 43.5%. Those add up to more than 100% because of the sportsbook's cut; scale them down and you get about 58% and 42%.

Now you can sort the week's matchups. A 75% favorite is close to a sure point. A 55% favorite is barely better than a coin flip, and that's the kind of game where an upset pick costs you little. If you'd rather not do the math, the point spread tells a similar story: the bigger the spread, the safer the favorite.

Our free NFL model picks give a model's view on the spread for each game, which is handy as a second opinion in against the spread pools.

Pick favorites, then choose your upsets carefully

If you only pick favorites, you'll do fine but rarely finish first, because a lot of other people will have the same card. If you pick lots of upsets, you'll finish near the bottom most weeks. The answer sits in between, and it depends on two things: how close the game is, and how many people in your pool are on the favorite.

Look at it this way. Say 90% of your pool takes a 60% favorite. If the favorite wins, you gained nothing by picking it, because almost everyone has the same point. If the underdog wins and you had it, you just gained a point on 90% of the pool. That's the value of a contrarian pick: you don't take the dog because it's likely, you take it because, when it hits, it moves you past most of the field at once.

Pick popularity is the hard part to guess. Big-name teams, prime-time games and whichever team was on TV last week all draw more picks than the odds justify. Our NFL consensus picks show which side most players are on, which is a fair stand-in for what your pool is doing.

How pool size changes your pick'em strategy

Pool sizeApproach
Small office pool (under 20)Mostly favorites. One upset pick on a near coin-flip game is enough.
Medium (20 to 100)Favorites in lopsided games, two or three contrarian picks on close, popular games.
Large (100+)You need to be different to win. Three or four calculated upsets a week, never on huge favorites.

In an office pool of 12 people, you might win just by being steady. In a public contest with thousands of entries, steady gets you lost somewhere in the middle of the standings. The bigger the pool, the more you have to separate yourself, and the more risk you have to take to do it.

Weekly prizes vs. season-long standings

Weekly winners and season-long winners need different thinking. A weekly prize is a fresh small contest every week, so you can afford a bolder card: a 12-person pool's weekly prize is usually won by someone who got the coin-flip games right.

A season-long prize rewards steady accuracy. Early in the NFL season, play it close to the odds and build a good total. Then look at where you stand. If you're leading late, copy what the chasing pack is likely to pick so they can't gain on you. If you're behind, you have to pick differently from the leader, because on every game where you both have the same team, the gap can't change.

That second point is simple math, and people forget it. Say you're 3 points back in a straight-up pool with one week left. You only gain or lose ground on games where your pick differs from the leader's. Pick differently in 2 games and the best you can do is cut it to 1. To finish ahead you need at least 4 different picks and you'd have to win every one of them. With 6 different picks, you could afford to lose one.

Don't lose the tiebreaker by accident

Most NFL pools break ties with a guess at the total points in the last game of the week, often Monday Night Football. People type in a random number like 45 and lose a tie they could have won. Use the betting total for that game as your starting point: it's the market's best guess at combined points. If it's 44.5, guess 44 or 45, unless you've got a real reason to lean higher or lower. In a big pool, guessing a few points off the total is a fair way to avoid landing on the same number as everyone else.

Habits that win pick'em pools over a season

Make your picks late in the week if your pool allows it, after the injury reports and quarterback news are out, but set a reminder so you never miss the deadline. A missed pick is a free loss. Don't pick with your heart: your favorite team doesn't win more often because you need it to. Don't chase after a bad week by loading up on longshots, either. And keep a quick note of your contrarian picks, so at the end of the season you can see whether they were helping or just costing you points.

A lot of the same thinking carries over to survivor pools, where pick popularity matters even more, and our week-by-week NFL pick'em routine turns all of this into a checklist for football season. For college slates, where there are more games and bigger spreads, see our tips for college pick'em slates.

Pick'em pools are one of several kinds of free sports contests that pay real money. If you want something to play between pool weeks, our free Streak and Monthly Contest put the same skill, reading a line and picking a side, up against a cash prize. The rules are on the contests page.

Streak for the Cash is for players 21 and over. If betting ever stops being fun, call or text 1-800-GAMBLER for free, confidential help.

FAQ

Should you pick all favorites in a pick'em pool?
In a small pool, mostly yes. In a big pool, all favorites gives you the same card as half the field, so you need a few well-chosen underdogs to have a real shot at first place.
How many upsets should you pick each week?
There's no fixed number. In a pool of 10 or 20 people, one or two close games is plenty. In a pool of several hundred, three or four, always on games the betting line says are close.
What's a good tiebreaker guess?
Start from the betting total for the tiebreaker game, which is the market's best guess at combined points, and nudge it up or down only if you have a reason.
Is a straight-up pool easier than an against-the-spread pool?
It's easier to get picks right straight up, because favorites win most games. Against the spread, every game is close to a coin flip, so the standings are more random and the edge comes from small things like stale lines.

Build a streak today

15 in a row = $100 · 21 in a row = $1,500 · Free to play.

Join free

More from Sports Contests