Sports Contests

College Football Bowl Pick'em: How Bowl Pools Work and How to Win One

6 min read
College football bowl pick'em pool

Bowl season is the one time a year your aunt, your coworker and the guy who only watches Alabama all fill out the same sheet. A bowl pick'em asks you to pick the winner of every college football bowl game, usually including the College Football Playoff, and the player with the most right picks (or most points) when the last game ends wins. Simple enough. Winning one is harder, because bowl games are the strangest games of the college season.

Teams have been off for weeks. Stars sit out to protect their draft stock. Coaches leave for new jobs before the game. One team is thrilled to be there and the other is annoyed it's playing in late December instead of the playoff. All of that matters more than the regular-season record, and that's where you can beat the people picking by logo.

How a college football bowl pick'em works

Before the first bowl kicks off, you make your picks for every game on the list. Most pools lock the whole sheet at once, so a pick made in mid-December has to hold up for a game on New Year's Day. Some newer apps let you pick each game until it starts, which is a big help with late opt-out news.

Straight-up scoring gives one point for each correct pick. It's easy to run and it's what most office pools use. Against-the-spread pools make your pick cover the line, so a 14-point favorite has to win by 15, and every game turns into something close to a coin flip. Confidence pools have you rank every game: with 40 games on the sheet, your surest pick is worth 40 and your least sure is worth 1. Most of the big free contests use some version of that last one.

Ties in the standings are usually broken by guessing the total points in the national championship game, so keep that number in mind too.

Where to play a bowl pick'em

Every December you'll find plenty of options. The bowls themselves run an official Bowl Season pick'em game, the big sports sites like ESPN, CBS and Yahoo all host free contests with prizes, and pool hosting sites let you build a private college football bowl pick'em for your office or family with your own point values. Most of the free ones only ask you to sign up for an account and make your picks before the first bowl kicks off. Read the contest rules for the entry deadline (some let you edit a pick until that game's kickoff, others lock everything at the first one) and for who's eligible to win the prize.

For a family pool, a printed sheet or a shared spreadsheet still works fine. Just agree on the scoring and the tiebreaker before the first game.

Why bowl games are different

Regular-season form only goes so far in a bowl. A few things matter more in December than they did in October.

Opt-outs and the transfer portal

Players who expect to be drafted often skip non-playoff bowls, and many others are already looking at new schools through the transfer portal. A team losing its starting quarterback and top two receivers is a different team. Check opt-out news right before your deadline, and if your pool lets you pick game by game, wait as long as you can on the games with question marks.

Coaching changes

When a head coach takes another job, an interim coach often runs the bowl. Some teams play loose and fired up for the interim guy; others look like they're already on vacation. You can't know for sure, but a team in turmoil deserves less of your confidence.

Motivation

A good team that just missed the playoff can come out flat in a lower-tier bowl. A program in its first bowl in years might treat the game like a title. This is where the "who wants it more" talk actually has some truth to it. Read the beat coverage, not just the records.

The long layoff

Teams can go three or four weeks without a game. Rust hits offenses harder than defenses, and the first quarter of a lot of bowls looks sloppy. It's one reason upsets show up more in bowl season than in November.

A game plan for confidence-point bowl pools

If your pool uses confidence points, the order you give your picks matters as much as the picks themselves. We build ours in this order.

Start with the betting lines. The spread is the best free estimate of how likely each favorite is to win, and it already includes a lot of the news. Sort the games from biggest favorite to smallest, then adjust. Push a game down your list if the favorite has big opt-outs or a coaching mess. Push it up if the underdog is the team missing key players.

Put your highest numbers on the favorites you trust most, not on your upset picks. The upset you love is still more likely to lose than win; give it a middle number so a miss doesn't wreck your total. Then pick a few spots to be different from the crowd. In a big pool everyone takes the same favorites, so a well-chosen underdog on a small number is how you separate. Our strategy for ranking confidence picks covers this point-by-point in more depth.

Save some thought for the playoff games. They usually carry big points, involve the best teams with the fewest opt-outs, and they're where a pool often gets decided.

Straight-up and spread pools

In a straight-up pool, pick most favorites and only take an underdog when you have a reason: key opt-outs on the other side, a coaching change, or a line under a field goal. In a big field, you'll need a few calculated upsets to climb past the people who pick every favorite.

In a spread pool, favorites have no built-in edge. Line value matters more here. Look at how the line moved since it opened: when a number moves a lot toward one team, it often means news (like an opt-out) hit the market. Our free college football model picks give you a second opinion on each side if you want a check on your gut.

Mistakes we see every bowl season

Picking with your heart is the big one. Every pool has someone who picks their alma mater in a game it's a 10-point underdog, with max confidence. Love your team, but give it the honest number.

Locking the sheet too early is the second. If the pool doesn't lock until the first bowl, there's no prize for finishing your picks the day the matchups come out. Opt-out news piles up through December.

And forgetting the tiebreaker. Plenty of bowl pools come down to the championship-game points guess. Start from that game's betting total instead of a random number.

If you play college football pick'em during the season too, many of the same habits carry over; we laid them out in our tips for weekly college pick'em pools.

Keep the sweat going after the bowls

When the last bowl is over, the NFL playoffs are just starting, and pool season keeps going. If survivor is more your style, the NFL version of last-man-standing is worth learning for next fall. In the meantime, our Streak runs all year: free picks on spreads and totals, where a run of 15, 17, 19 or 21 wins pays cash. It's a nice way to keep score on your college football reads once the bowl sheet is graded.

You must be 21 or older to play. Keep it fun, keep it small, and if gambling stops being fun, call 1-800-GAMBLER.

FAQ

How does a bowl pick'em work?
You pick the winner of every college football bowl game on the list, usually including the College Football Playoff games, before the first bowl kicks off. Each right pick scores points, and the player with the most points when the last game ends wins the pool.
How do confidence points work in bowl pick'em?
You rank every game by how sure you are. With 40 games, your surest pick gets 40 points and your least sure gets 1. A right pick earns its points, a wrong one earns nothing, and each number is used once.
Should I pick bowl games straight up or against the spread?
That's the pool's choice, not yours. Straight-up pools reward picking favorites with good motivation. Spread pools make every game close to a coin flip, so line value and late news matter more.
Are bowl pick'em pools free?
Many are. Big sports sites run free bowl pick'em games every year, and lots of office and family pools are free or cheap. If money is involved, keep the entry small and know the payout rules.
How do opt-outs affect bowl picks?
A lot. Players heading to the NFL draft or the transfer portal often skip bowl games, and a team missing its quarterback or top receivers can look nothing like its regular-season self. Check the news right before the deadline.

Build a streak today

15 in a row = $100 · 21 in a row = $1,500 · Free to play.

Join free

More from Sports Contests