Sports Contests

March Madness Bracket Tips: How to Pick Upsets and Win Your Pool

6 min read
March Madness bracket tips

Selection Sunday night. The NCAA tournament field of 68 is out, you've got a blank bracket and a few days, and somebody in your group chat has already filled out theirs with a 15 seed in the Elite Eight. Don't be that person.

The best March Madness bracket tips come down to a few habits: pick your champion first, trust the betting lines and power ratings more than the seeds, save your upsets for the first-round games that are close to a coin flip, and pick more favorites the deeper you go. Then adjust for your pool's size and scoring. That's what separates a bracket that wins a pool from one that's fun for about 36 hours.

Know your pool's scoring before you pick a single game

Most bracket challenge games double the points every round. A common system is 1 point per correct pick in the first round, then 2, 4, 8, 16 and 32 for the national championship game. ESPN-style scoring does the same at ten times the size: 10, 20, 40, 80, 160 and 320.

Run the math. There are 32 first-round games at 1 point each, so the whole first round is worth 32 points. The champion alone is also worth 32. Every round is worth the same total, which means getting the title team right counts as much as nailing all 32 first-round games.

Some pools add an upset bonus (extra points for a lower seed winning, often the seed difference). If yours does, upset picks get more valuable and you can be bolder early. If it doesn't, an upset pick is just a pick with a lower chance of being right.

Pick your champion first and work backward

Since the late rounds carry the weight, start at the end. Choose your national champion, then your Final Four, then fill in the paths that get them there. Doing it the other way, game by game from the first round, is how people end up with a champion they never meant to pick.

The title nearly always goes to one of the very best teams in the country. Cinderella runs are real and great TV, but they tend to end in the Sweet 16 or Elite Eight. Pick a champion from the handful of teams the ratings and the futures odds like most. In a small pool, the favorite is fine. In a big pool, read on.

Trust the betting lines and ratings over the seeds

Seeds are set by a committee on Selection Sunday, and they're a rough guide. A 7 seed can be better than the 2 seed in its region. A 10 seed from a power conference can be a stronger team than the 7 seed it's facing. Seeding reflects a team's résumé over a whole season, which isn't always the same as how good it is on a Thursday afternoon in March.

The betting markets do a much better job. Look up the first-round point spreads: an 11 seed that's only a 1.5-point underdog is a near coin flip, whatever the numbers next to the names say. A 12 seed getting 8 points is a long shot. Power ratings that measure efficiency (points scored and allowed per possession, adjusted for opponents) tell a similar story, and they're free to look up. Our college basketball computer picks give a model's take on each game, which is a handy second opinion when the seeds and the lines don't agree.

We'd pick from the lines every time. Millions of dollars push them toward the real odds, and your gut was formed by watching three of these teams play once in February.

Where first-round upsets actually happen

Upsets are the fun part, and the part that wrecks most brackets. Some matchups produce a lot of them. Others almost never do.

The 8 vs 9 game is basically a toss-up, so "upset" barely applies. The 7 vs 10 and 6 vs 11 games are close enough that the underdog wins often, and an 11 seed coming out of the First Four in Dayton is worth a long look: those teams have already won a tournament game, and VCU rode that path all the way to the Final Four in 2011. The 5 vs 12 game is the one everyone circles, because 12 seeds win it more often than the gap between them suggests.

Below that, be careful. A 4 seed loses to a 13 now and then, and a 3 seed falls to a 14 once in a while. A 2 seed losing to a 15 is rare enough to be a headline. A 1 seed losing to a 16 has happened so seldom that picking it is throwing away a point.

Our rule of thumb: pick three to five first-round upsets, all in games where the line is within a few points, and never because of a mascot.

Pick more favorites in the later rounds

Early upsets are where most brackets get burned. Every upset you pick early has to keep winning for your bracket to keep scoring. If you send a 12 seed to the Sweet 16 and it loses on Thursday, you lose that game and the next one, and if you had it in the Elite Eight you've lost three.

The better teams win more often as the NCAA tournament field shrinks, because the weak matchups are gone. By the Sweet 16 most of the games are between good teams, and the higher seed wins more than its share. Lean on favorites from the second round on, and save your boldest call for one Final Four spot.

That one bold call is worth making. It's rare for all four 1 seeds to reach the Final Four together, so a bracket with a 2 or 3 seed (one the ratings rate highly) in the Final Four is usually closer to reality than a chalk bracket.

Match your bracket to your pool size

Casual players skip this step, and in a big pool it matters more than any single upset. In a bracket pool of 10 friends, a mostly chalk bracket with the favorite as champion is a strong entry, because you only have to beat nine people. In a pool of 500, a chalk bracket ties with dozens of other chalk brackets, and you need something different to finish alone at the top.

The smartest place to be different is your champion. If a third of your pool picks the same team, you split the credit with all of them when it wins. A contrarian champion, one the ratings like nearly as much but the public mostly ignores, is worth more to you in a big pool. Most bracket game sites show how often each team was picked nationwide, and that public pick data is a decent stand-in for what your pool is doing.

It's the same thinking we use in a weekly pick'em: you gain ground only on the games where you're on a different side from the people you're chasing.

A few habits that help every March

Fill out your bracket after the First Four if your game lets you, and check injury news before you lock it. Brackets lock when the first round tips off on Thursday, and late news about a star's ankle can move a game's spread by a couple of points.

Don't pick your alma mater to win it all unless the numbers do too. Don't copy the TV analyst who's paid to be interesting. And if you play more than one bracket, give each one a different champion, otherwise you're just paying twice for the same entry.

If you want the full step-by-step, from reading the bracket to the tiebreaker, see our guide on filling out a bracket step by step. Some groups skip brackets entirely and run a March Madness survivor pool, which plays a lot like survivor in football: one pick a round, each team once.

March on Streak for the Cash

We don't run a bracket contest, but March is one of the best months of the year for the Streak. Every day of the tournament is packed with college basketball, and each game is a chance to add a win to your run. Pick one side at a time from the college basketball odds, build your streak and see where it puts you in the Streak standings. It's free, and long streaks pay cash.

Streak for the Cash is for players 21 and over. If betting ever stops being fun, call or text 1-800-GAMBLER for free, confidential help.

FAQ

What is the best strategy for a March Madness bracket?
Pick your champion first, since the late rounds are worth the most points in most pools. Use betting lines and power ratings instead of seeds, take a few first-round upsets in close games, and pick more favorites the deeper you go.
How many upsets should I pick in my bracket?
A handful in the first round, mostly in the 8 vs 9, 7 vs 10, 6 vs 11 and 5 vs 12 games where the betting line says it's close. Picking lots of upsets in later rounds usually costs you more points than it wins.
Should I pick all four 1 seeds to make the Final Four?
It's rare for all four 1 seeds to reach the Final Four together, so in most years a bracket with at least one other team in the Final Four is the better bet. Which 1 seed to fade should come from the ratings, not a hunch.
What are the odds of a perfect March Madness bracket?
If every game were a coin flip, the odds would be 1 in 2 to the 63rd power, about 1 in 9.2 quintillion. Knowing some basketball improves that a lot, but a perfect bracket is still close to impossible.
Does Streak for the Cash have a bracket contest?
Not right now. During March Madness you can make free Streak picks on college basketball games and build a winning streak toward cash prizes.

Build a streak today

15 in a row = $100 · 21 in a row = $1,500 · Free to play.

Join free

More from Sports Contests