Sports Contests

Sports Handicapping Contests: How They Work and How to Win One

6 min read
Sports handicapping contests explained

A sports handicapping contest is a competition where you make picks on real games, usually against the point spread or at posted odds, and the players with the best record or the biggest balance at the end win prizes. You don't bet your own money on the games themselves. You're scored on how good your picks are, against everyone else in the contest.

We've run free handicapping contests for years, so we've seen most of the formats and most of the ways people lose them.

How handicapping contests are scored

Contests differ mostly in how your picks turn into points. There are three common formats, and they reward different habits.

The classic NFL format is your record against the spread. Each NFL week you pick a set number of games against the spread, often five, and you get a point for each win and usually half a point for a push. The best record at the end of the regular season wins. The best-known Las Vegas NFL contests work this way and charge a four-figure entry fee, with lines locked when they're posted so everyone picks off the same numbers.

The second format is a bankroll or units contest. Everyone starts with the same play balance and bets it at real odds on spreads, moneylines and totals. Winning bets grow the balance, losing bets shrink it, and the biggest balance wins. Because the odds matter, an underdog win at +150 is worth more than a favorite win at -150, just like a real wager. This is the closest thing to real sports betting without the risk.

Then there are streaks: one pick at a time, and only consecutive wins count. One loss and you're back to zero. It sounds simple, and it's brutal.

Pick'em pools are close cousins: straight-up or spread picks for every game on the slate, scored by wins. Some contests mix these formats, or add a minimum number of picks so nobody can win with a 3-0 record. A few rank handicappers by return on investment over a full season, which is how many sites that sell betting picks rate their experts.

Free contests and entry-fee contests

Paid contests take an entry fee and pay most of it back out as prizes, so the top prize can be huge. They also draw the sharpest players. Free contests cost nothing, and the prizes are smaller, but you're up against a field that's mostly casual, which is a real edge if you take it seriously.

Sportsbooks run a lot of free contests too, as a way to bring in new customers. Read those terms closely. Some pay prizes in sportsbook credit that you have to bet several times over before you can withdraw it, and some only let you enter after you've made a deposit. A prize you can't cash out isn't much of a prize. Our guide to free sports contests to win money covers how to tell a real one from a sign-up funnel.

The rules to read before you enter

Most people skim the rules, then find out in week 9 that a push counts as a loss. Before you make a pick, find these:

  • Which lines count: fixed contest lines posted once a week, or live lines that move until kickoff.
  • Pick deadlines, and whether you can change a pick before the game starts.
  • How pushes, postponed games and canceled games are graded.
  • Which bet types are allowed (spread, moneyline, total, player props, parlays, teasers) and any odds limits.
  • Minimum picks to qualify, and how ties are broken.
  • What the prizes are, how many places get paid, and how prizes are paid.

Odds limits matter more than people think. In our Monthly Contest, for example, every bet has to be priced -140 or longer, so you can't pile into huge favorites to protect a lead.

Betting strategy for handicapping contests

Contest strategy isn't the same as betting strategy, and that trips up a lot of good sports bettors. In real betting you only need to beat the sportsbook. In a contest you need to beat every other player, which changes how much risk you should take and when.

Pick fewer, better games

Handicap every game you like, then cut the list. If the format lets you choose how many bets to make, don't fire at everything on the board. The best handicappers we've watched pass on most games and bet the handful where they have a real reason to disagree with the line: a key injury, a bad matchup, weather, a team on a short week. If you can't say why the line is wrong, it's not one of your best bets. Our guide to picking winners walks through how to find those games.

Use the odds to your advantage

In a bankroll contest, plus-money underdogs move you up faster. A $5 bet at -110 wins $4.55; the same bet on an underdog at +150 wins $7.50. That doesn't mean you should bet every underdog, but when you like a dog, the payout is part of the case for it. Moneylines on underdogs you really believe in, and totals in games with a clear weather or pace angle are where contest players often find their edge.

Know where you stand

Early in a contest, play it straight: bet your best reads at normal size. Late in the contest, look at the leaderboard. If you're well behind with two weeks left, safe picks won't catch anyone and don't give you a real chance to win, so you need some bigger-payout spots. If you're leading, you can afford to avoid the coin flips everyone else is chasing. A parlay is usually a bad bet, but at the end of a contest it can be the only way to make up ground, if the rules allow one.

Don't follow the crowd blindly

In a big contest, the most popular side of a game doesn't help you pass anyone, because half the field has it too. Check the NFL public splits to see where the crowd is. When you agree with the crowd, fine, but the picks that move you up the standings are usually the good ones the crowd doesn't like.

Track every pick

Write down each pick, the line, why you made it and the result. After a season you'll know which of your reasons win and which are just habits. Against the spread at -110 you need 52.4% to break even as a bettor; anything around 55% over a full season is very good, and in a weekly NFL contest, a few points above that usually puts you near the top.

Sports and seasons

NFL betting is the biggest draw for handicapping contests by far, with weekly contests running from September through the playoffs. College football contests are popular too, with bigger spreads and more games to choose from. In the spring and summer, MLB and NHL contests use moneylines and run lines or puck lines more than spreads. Bankroll-style contests like ours run all year across every league, so you can play the sport you know best. Some contests also take UFC fights, golf or soccer on the moneyline.

Our free handicapping contests

Streak for the Cash runs two free contests, and the Monthly Contest is a straight handicapping contest in the bankroll format. On the 1st of every month every player gets a $100 Contest Balance. Every Contest bet is $5, on a spread, moneyline, total or player prop at -140 or longer, and wins go back into your Contest Balance. The Monthly Contest leaderboard ranks everyone by balance, and at the end of the month the top three win $25, $15 and $10, paid by PayPal. Players tied on the same balance split the prizes for the places they cover.

Only games that start before the month ends can be Contest bets, and anything still pending when the month closes is voided, so a late-month parlay of next week's games isn't an option. The Monthly Contest rules spell out the rest.

The other is the Streak: one pick at a time on a spread or total, and 15 wins in a row pays $100, up to $1,500 for 21. And when the NFL season starts, our season-long NFL survivor pool tests a different skill altogether: picking one winner a week without ever using a team twice. You can see all of today's games and lines without signing up.

You must be 21 or older to play. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

FAQ

What is a sports handicapping contest?
It's a competition where players make picks on real games, usually against the point spread or at posted odds, and the best record or biggest balance wins prizes. Some are free to enter and some charge an entry fee that goes into the prize pool.
Are free handicapping contests legit?
Many are. A legit contest posts its rules, prizes and how winners get paid before you enter, and never asks for a deposit to claim a prize. Be careful with contests that pay only in sportsbook credit you have to roll over before you can withdraw it.
How many picks do you need to win a handicapping contest?
It depends on the format. Weekly NFL contests usually ask for a set number of picks each week, often five. Bankroll contests have no fixed number, but you need enough winning bets to grow your balance past everyone else's, and most have a minimum to qualify.
Do sports handicapping contests pay real money?
The good ones do. Streak for the Cash pays its Monthly Contest and Streak prizes by PayPal. Other contests pay in cash, gift cards or sportsbook credit, so check the prize terms first.

Build a streak today

15 in a row = $100 · 21 in a row = $1,500 · Free to play.

Join free

More from Sports Contests