Sports Contests

How to Pick Winners in Sports: Winning Picks and Smarter Bets

8 min read
How to pick winners in sports

To pick winners in sports, for a contest or a sports bet, start with the betting odds: they already tell you how likely each team is to win, and they're right more often than any single expert. Then look for a specific reason the odds might be off (an injury, a mismatch, a tired team), pick or bet only the games where you have one, and write every pick down so you learn which reasons actually work.

We've run free picking contests for years, and the players who climb our leaderboard tend to be the ones who pass on most games. The same habit makes for better sports bets.

Start with what the odds already know

A sportsbook line is a prediction built from models, injury reports and the money of thousands of bettors. It isn't perfect, but it's a better starting point than your gut. The trick is to read it as each team's chance of winning instead of a payout.

For a favorite with minus odds, divide the odds by the odds plus 100. A team at -200 is 200 ÷ 300, or about a 67% chance. For an underdog with plus odds, divide 100 by the odds plus 100. A team at +200 is 100 ÷ 300, about 33%. Those two add up to 100% here; at a real sportsbook they add up to a bit more, because the sportsbook builds its margin into both sides.

MoneylineImplied win chance
-30075%
-20066.7%
-15060%
-11052.4%
+15040%
+20033.3%
+30025%

Even a -300 favorite loses one game in four, which is why picking winners is hard: the obvious team usually wins, but "usually" leaves plenty of room for your pick to go wrong, and you can't get rich picking every favorite because everyone else is doing it too.

Straight up or against the spread

Before you pick or bet, know what kind of winner you're picking. These are the two main types of bets for a side. Straight up (a moneyline bet) means the team just has to win the game. Against the spread (a spread bet) means it has to win by more than the point spread (or the underdog has to lose by less). A 7-point favorite might win 75% of the time straight up and still only cover about half the time, because the spread is set to make both sides close to a coin flip.

So the skill changes with the format. In a survivor pool or a straight-up pick'em, your job is mostly to avoid upsets. In a spread contest, it's to find the handful of lines that look a point or two off. Our NFL pool strategy guide goes through both kinds of pools week by week.

Look at the matchup, not the standings

Records lie a little. A 6-2 team that won five one-score games is probably not as good as a 5-3 team that lost three close ones. Points scored and allowed per game, adjusted for who they played, tell you more than wins and losses.

Then look at how the two teams fit together. A team that can't stop the run against an opponent that runs it 35 times a game. A slow-paced basketball team against one that wants to run. A strong home team against a club on its third road game in five nights. These are the things that move a real game, and sometimes the line doesn't fully account for them.

Each sport has its own big lever, and it changes how you bet on sports. In the NFL it's the quarterback. In MLB it's the starting pitcher, which is why baseball odds can change so much from one day to the next. In the NBA, rest days and which stars are playing. In the NHL, the starting goalie. In college football, the talent gap between programs is huge, so the question is often how much a big favorite wins by, not whether it wins.

Check the news right before you pick

The single most common way to lose a pick you liked is news you didn't see. Late scratches, a quarterback listed as questionable who doesn't play, a pitcher pushed back a day, wind blowing in at the ballpark. Make your pick as close to game time as you reasonably can, and if the line has moved a lot since it opened, find out why before you go against it. Big moves usually mean the market learned something.

Pick your spots

This is the part most people skip. You don't have to have an opinion on every game, and you don't have to bet every game either. If your read agrees with the odds, the pick is probably right, but it doesn't give you an edge over anyone else in the contest. The picks that win contests, and the sports bets that win money, are the few where you have a clear reason to disagree with the line and the crowd.

A good habit: before you lock a pick, finish the sentence "The line is wrong because..." If you can't, pass. In our Streak game that's built right in, because you only make one pick at a time and nothing forces you to play today. The players with the long streaks wait for the game they like.

It helps to know where the crowd is. Our NFL pick percentages show which side most players are on, and our computer's NFL picks give a model's view to check your own against. Neither should make the pick for you, but if you're on the same side as 85% of the public and the model, ask yourself what you know that the line doesn't.

Winning picks vs winning bets

Here's where a contest pick and a sports bet part ways. In a straight-up pool, a winner is a winner. When you bet, the price matters as much as the result, because a winning bet at a bad price can still lose you money over time.

Say you think a team wins 60% of the time. At -150 the sportsbook gives it 60% too, so there's no edge: win or lose, that's a fair wager at best, and with the book's margin it's a little worse. At -120 the same team is a value bet, because the price implies only 54.5%. And an underdog at +180 (35.7% implied) can be the smarter bet even though it'll lose more often than it wins, if you think its real chance is 40%. Most sports betting strategies that hold up over a season come back to this: find the gap between your number and the sportsbook's number, then bet only when it's big enough.

Two more things separate a bettor who lasts from one who doesn't. Shop for the best odds, since the sportsbooks don't all post the same price and half a point or 10 cents on the payout adds up over hundreds of bets. And use bankroll management: bet the same small share of your bankroll on every pick (1% to 3% is a common range), so a cold week can't knock you out. Expert picks and paid services can give you ideas, but no tipster changes that math.

Keep your emotions out of it

Fans overrate their own teams and underrate their rivals. Everyone overreacts to the last game they watched. And after a bad loss, the urge to win it back with the next pick is strong. None of that helps you pick winners.

Two simple rules go a long way. Leave your favorite team alone, or at least pick it only when you'd pick it if it were someone else's team. And don't make a pick just because you lost the last one. If you're putting money on games, the same goes for your bankroll: a fixed small amount every time beats bigger bets to chase losses, and anyone 21 or older playing for real money should set a limit before the season starts.

Track every pick

You can't tell skill from luck without a record. Write down every pick and every bet, the line when you made it, why you made it, and the result. After 50 or 100 picks, look at which reasons were winning and which weren't. Maybe your injury reads are good and your weather reads are not. That's the kind of thing you only find out on paper.

Know the benchmark too. Against the spread at standard -110 odds, a bettor needs to win 52.4% to break even, and anything around 55% over a big sample is excellent. Anyone claiming 70% against the spread over hundreds of picks is selling something. If you want a fuller process, from building a simple power rating to adjusting for news, see our sports prediction guide.

Common ways good pickers go wrong

Taking too many favorites in a contest with lots of players, or betting every big favorite on the board. It feels safe, but if you pick the same teams as everyone else you can't finish ahead of them. In big pools, one or two smart underdog picks are how you separate. Our guide on beating a big pick'em pool explains when that's worth the risk.

Stacking picks together. Parlays and multi-pick cards have a bigger payout because they're much harder to hit. Three picks that are each 60% likely all win together only about 22% of the time, which is why a three-team parlay pays around 6 to 1 and still isn't a great bet.

Trusting streaks. A team that covered five in a row is not more likely to cover the sixth. A player who hit 8 straight picks probably got some bounces. Short runs are mostly noise, good and bad. The same goes for live betting after a hot first quarter: one quarter isn't a trend.

Test your picks for free

The best way to get better at picking winners is to pick real games and keep score, and you don't need to bet money to do it. On Streak for the Cash, the free Streak lets you make one pick at a time on a point spread or a total priced -140 or longer. Each win adds one, a loss sends you back to zero, and 15 wins in a row pays $100 (17 pays $250, 19 pays $500 and 21 pays $1,500). It's the most honest scorecard we know of. Browse today's betting lines, read how the Streak is graded, and keep an eye on the current standings to see who's on a run. In the fall, survivor picks during NFL season are a good straight-up test too.

You must be 21 or older to play. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

FAQ

What is the best way to pick winners in sports?
Start with the betting odds, because they are the most accurate free forecast there is. Turn them into win chances, then only go against them when you have a specific reason, like an injury or a bad matchup the line hasn't caught up with. Track every pick so you know whether your reasons are any good.
What does +200 odds mean?
+200 means the team is an underdog and a $100 bet wins $200, plus your $100 back. In win-chance terms the odds give that team about a 33% chance to win (100 divided by 300).
What is the most successful sport to bet on?
There isn't one that's easy. Every major sport has sharp betting markets. Many people do best in a sport they follow closely and a league that gets less attention, like a single college conference, because that's where their knowledge is ahead of the crowd.
What percentage of sports bettors win?
Only a small share of bettors come out ahead over the long run. At standard -110 odds you need to win 52.4% of your bets just to break even, and most people don't. Free contests are a good way to find out how good your picks are before any money is involved.

Build a streak today

15 in a row = $100 · 21 in a row = $1,500 · Free to play.

Join free

More from Sports Contests