Top 5 NCAAF Teams to Watch: A MyBookie Review of Early Season Rankings
When the 2025 college football season kicked off, everyone was watching the top contenders. Who was hot, who looked ready to win it all, and who probably wasn't worth backing? The preseason AP Top 25 rankings had Texas, Penn State and Ohio State in the top three spots.
Note: this preview was written in early September 2025, after the opening week. The 2025 season has since finished, so the rankings, odds and win totals below are a snapshot of how things looked at the time, not current prices.
Our top five NCAAF teams
Based on the AP polls and MyBookie ag reviews, these are the five NCAAF teams we picked out to watch at the start of the 2025 college football season:
1. Texas Longhorns
The Longhorns opened the season at No. 1 in the preseason AP Top 25 rankings, a big turnaround from the program's lean years. Quarterback Arch Manning, of the famous Manning family, came in as a Heisman favorite, which put a spotlight on the team. MyBookie still saw the Longhorns as a volatile pick that could pay off, but one that might crack if early pressure built up. After their Week 1 loss, the Longhorns were listed at +700 to win the National Championship, with a season win total of 9.5 and the over priced at -110. Arch Manning's touchdown and passing yard totals were the obvious prop markets to watch.
2. Penn State Nittany Lions
Penn State was another strong contender, and the Nittany Lions had been here before. In 2024 they finished 13-3 and reached the College Football Playoff semifinal at the Orange Bowl. Running back Nick Singleton started the season within reach of Saquon Barkley's school touchdown record. With their balance and experience, the Nittany Lions looked like one of the steadier teams on the board, though no team is ever a sure thing. The markets had them at +700 to win the Championship, with the over on their 10.5 win total at even money, and prop bets such as Singleton's rushing touchdowns were getting attention.
3. Ohio State Buckeyes
The 2024 national champion started at No. 3 in the preseason AP poll, but the Buckeyes got going fast, knocking the Texas Longhorns down a peg in Week 1. That's why so many analysts and bookmakers rated them highly and expected them to keep winning. With preseason futures odds of +600 to win the national championship, their quick climb to the top wasn't much of a surprise. For bettors, their win total was set at 10.5 with the over at -120.
4. Clemson Tigers
Clemson sat comfortably in the preseason top five, but the opening-week performance against LCU (LSU), a home loss, took a bit of the shine off. The Tigers were still seen as serious playoff contenders, with a reliable defense and lots of returning talent. MyBookie ag reviews rated them as a team worth watching. At the time, the markets had them at +2,500 for the title, with the over on their 9.5 win total at -110.
5. Georgia Bulldogs
Georgia was the other top team to watch. The Bulldogs finished 11-3 in 2024 and won the SEC Championship. New starting quarterback Gunner Stockton could run as well as throw, and the offense looked quicker and more dangerous with him. Many expected the Bulldogs to challenge for another SEC title and a College Football Playoff spot. Some thought they were undervalued at +700 to win the title, with their win total at 9.5 and the over at -130. Their SEC title odds of +360 and over/under bets on Stockton's total touchdowns were other popular markets.
What bettors and fans could expect
The 2025 season looked likely to bring plenty of surprises and upsets. This is how we saw the top contenders in early September:
Texas, Ohio State, Penn State, Clemson, Georgia and Notre Dame were the clear early-season favorites.
Ohio State's Week 1 win over Texas made it one of the clear leaders.
Notre Dame was worth keeping an eye on and could surprise people.
We expected these teams to set the pace for the season.
Overall, the 2025 college football season looked like it would have some great performances. Texas' volatility, Ohio State's momentum from its title run and Georgia's dual-threat offense were the storylines we expected to shape the season. Preseason odds are only a starting point, so if you bet on college football, compare prices, keep your stakes within a set budget, and remember that even the strongest favorites lose games.
For week-by-week help with these teams, see our NCAAF picks today and the latest CFB consensus picks.
FAQ
What does +700 odds to win the national championship mean?
How do preseason rankings affect betting lines?
What is a season win total bet?
Build a streak today
15 in a row = $100 · 21 in a row = $1,500 · Free to play.
Rivalry Week Turns Fans Into Prediction JunkiesSeptember 9, 2026
2026 College Football Openers: Week 1 PicksAugust 7, 2026
Breaking Down the Clemson Tigers Spread Ahead of Key ACC BattlesOctober 1, 2025